Ok

En poursuivant votre navigation sur ce site, vous acceptez l'utilisation de cookies. Ces derniers assurent le bon fonctionnement de nos services. En savoir plus.

NMC

  • Nick J. Allen - Why the Telemachy? Vyāsa’s Answer

    Why the Telemachy? Vyāsa’s Answers 

    Nick J. Allen*

     

    *Institute of Social and Cultural Anthropology, University of Oxford

     

     

    Abstract: In the Odyssey the story of the main hero’s return from Troy to Ithaca is preceded by the Telemachy (the outward journey from Ithaca via Pylos to Sparta). The journeys of father and son overlap in time, and the travellers eventually converge at Eumaeus’ piggery. Many detailed parallels have already been found between Homer’s epics and the Mahābhārata (attributed to the sage Vyāsa), and the paper asks whether, here too, the overlapping journeys in the Greek have Sanskrit parallels. In fact, it is while the central hero Arjuna undertakes a visit to heaven that his brothers and wife undertake a pilgrimage around India; and the two journeys end in a reunion. A dozen rapprochements are presented linking the pairs of journeys recounted in the two epic traditions. The similarities are best explained by postulating a common origin within the Indo-European-speaking world.

    Keywords: Odyssey, Mahābhārata, Telemachy, Indo-European comparison, comparative epic, Otherworld journey, Hindu pilgrimage, Eumaeus.

    Résumé: Dans l’Odyssée le récit du nostos d’Ulysse (de Troie à Ithaque) est précédé de la Télémachie (voyage d’Ithaque à la Sparte, en passant par Pylos). Le voyage du père et celui du fils sont à peu près simultanés, et à la fin les voyageurs se réunissent chez Eumée. On a déjà trouvé beaucoup de rapprochements précis entre les épopées homériques et le Mahābhārata (dont l’origine est attribuée à Vyāsa); donc on en cherche ici aussi. En effet, c’est pendant qu’Arjuna (héros central de l’épopée) voyage pour visiter le Ciel que ses frères et sa femme vont en pèlerinage autour de l’Inde. On propose douze rapprochements entre les voyages appariés dans la tradition sanskrite et ceux appariés dans la tradition grecque. Les ressemblances sont expliquées au mieux par l’hypothèse d’une origine commune dans le cadre du monde indo-européen.

    Mots clés : Odyssée, Mahābhārata, Télémachie, comparaison indo-européenne, voyage au Ciel, pèlerinage hindou, Eumée.

     

    Télécharger le fichier en pdf / download in pdf: Allen.pdf

  • Ana R. Chelariu - Metamorphosis amid myths, initiation rites and Romanian folk tales

    Metamorphosis amid myths, initiation rites
    and Romanian folk tales
     

    Ana R. Chelariu*

     

    *New Jersey

     

     

    Abstract: In the discussion on myth-rite relations, the concept of metamorphosis occupies a significant place. The abundance of shape changings in myths and folktales leads to the hypothesis that they echo practices of initiation rites. This paper attempts to analyze the motif of transformations flight as found in myths and folktales and its connection with rites of passage. On a mythical level, the most common example of transformations flight is between a reluctant goddess or nymph and a god as seducer, best illustrated by the myth of Zeus and Nemesis. On a folklore level, the motif of transformations flight could show traces of a rite of initiation; special attention is given to Romanian folktales.

    Keywords: Initiation rites, the transformations flight, metamorphosis, Greek myths, Roman myths, Indo-Iranian myths, German myths, European folklore, Romanian folktales.

    Résumé: Dans la discussion sur les rapports entre mythe et rite, le concept de métamorphose occupe une place importante. L’abondance des changements d’aspect dans les mythes et les contes conduit à émettre l’hypothèse qu’ils font écho à des pratiques issues de rites d’initiation. Le présent article tente d’analyser le motif de l’envol via une métamorphose, que l’on retrouve dans les mythes et les contes, et de son lien avec les rites de passage. Sur le plan mythique, l’exemple le plus commun de ce type de transformation est celui d’une déesse réticente ou d’une nymphe, et d’un dieu séducteur, un exemple connu étant celui de Nemesis et Zeus. Sur le plan du folklore, le motif de l’envol après transformation pourrait montrer des traces d’un rite d’initiation. Une attention particulière est accordée aux contes roumains.

    Mots clés : Rites initiatiques, transformation pour voler, métamorphose, mythes grecs, mythes romains, mythes indo-iraniens, mythes allemands, folklore européen, contes roumains.

     

    Télécharger le fichier en pdf / download in pdf: Chelariu.pdf

     

  • Julien d'Huy - Première reconstruction statistique d'un rituel paléolithique: autour du motif du dragon

    Première reconstruction statistique d'un rituel paléolithique: autour du motif du dragon 

    Julien d'Huy*

     

    *

    IMAf UMR 8171 (CNRS/IRD/EHESS/Univ.Paris1/ EPHE/Aix-Marseille Univ-AMU)

     

     

    Abstract: In two great caves decorated in the Paleolithic : Montespan and Le Tuc d’Audoubert (out of which a river flows) there were found headless snake skeletons. One of them was a Colubrid, a particularly long snake. The fact that the skeletons are headless may reflect the snake’s dangerousness : the dangerous animals, like bison and lions, were often represented arrowed or headless, for instance at the Tuc d’Audoubert cave. 

    To understand the meaning of what was possibly an important ritual I have tried to statistically reconstruct the primal European Paleolithic folklore about the Snake.

    The software Paup4.0a147 and Mesquite2.75 were used to analyze a database of 42 mythological narratives concerning snakes (available here : http://ruthenia.ru/folklore/berezkin) and 22 geographical areas, each of them possessing more than ten narratives. The use of such a database was justified by a previous phylogenetic study of folktales concerning wild animals (d’Huy 2015) that showed a low correlation between the distribution of folk tales and geographical associations among populations, and established a parallel between the structure of phylogenetic trees built from folk tales and what we know of the first human migrations ; moreover, these phylogenetic trees allowed the reconstruction of the content of ancient tales corpora, e.g. Paleolithic.

    In this paper, a NeigbhorJoining (retention index : 0,52; fig.1), an UPGMA (retention index : 0,48; fig.2) and a majority rules consensus (RI : 0.54; fig.3) trees were build. The organization of these trees are similar to those obtained by the analysis of three other different databases : the first is about the stories where a rainbow snake drinks water on the ground, or in the sky (d’Huy on 2016 ; fig.4) ; the second, the fight against the dragon, based on many ethnic group’s beliefs (d’Huy 2014a ; fig.5) ; the third is based on some geographical areas and concerns the zoem of the dragon (d’Huy, 2013 ; fig.6). The results from these four independent, unrelated databases mostly coincide with respect to the topology of branching, and converge to strong conclusions about the evolution of snake folklore.

    Four almost identical trees have been reconstructed from the databases of the present paper (fig. 1, 2 and 3) and of d’Huy 2013 (fig.6). The human folklore about snakes seems to have left Africa in two steps. The first wave reached Oceania and then South America through the South and Southeast coast of Asia. This reconstructed wave is in agreement with the diffusion of the particular motif where a snake rainbow drinks water on the ground, or in the sky (fig. 4). Another wave left Africa to the Americas through central Asia (?). Finally, a late wave covered the major part of Eurasia, perhaps soon after the late glacial maximum. These two last waves are reflected in the two-step diffusion of the fight against the dragon (fig.5). 

    The results obtained from four different databases at distinct levels (the diffusion of a set of narratives, a set of traits about a zoem, a mythological motif, a narrative structure where different story elements serve the same narrative plot) using different levels of analysis (geographical area, cultural area, cultural groups) and different statistical tools (including NeigbhorJoining, UPGMA, Bayesian algorithms, parcimony, consensus) all fit the same scenario.

    Once the structural integrity of the NeigbhorJoining, the UPGMA and the consensus trees controlled by the three independent sources of evidence, it is important to note the strong closeness between the structure of these mythological trees and what we know about the first human migrations. It seems possible to accurately reconstruct the first human migrations from the diffusion of sets of folk tales, or of given mythological narratives, by using statistical tools.

    Using all phylogenetic trees studied in this paper and monitoring the results by observing the congruence between the results and the reconstructions obtained from two completely different databases (d’Huy 2013, 2014a, b) at the same geographical level, it becomes possible to securely reconstruct various features of the first European folklore about snakes. During the European Paleolithic period, people imagined mythological snakes being of natural size (100 % probability), or giant (75 % probability), possessing horns on the head (83 % probability) and having one or many heads (100 % probability) ; they sometimes possessed a diamond or magic treasure, could fly and produce rain and/or thunderstorms (75 % probability) and could fight against the thunder or against a giant bird (66.66 % probability). They could take the form of a rainbow (75 % probability). They were dangerous. They could prevent people from reaching water : permitting them, most of the time, only in exchange for sacrifices or valuable goods (100 % probability). Snakes were not only immortal, but were responsible death, for the mortality of man (100 % probability). And so it is possible that the headless snake skeletons of Montespan and of Le Tuc d’Audoubert reflect a ritual used to control rain and water by neutralizing, symbolically, the dangerous master : the dispenser of this precious element.

    This reconstructed myth may well have been illustrated by a Paleolithic image found in the cave of La Madeleine, in Dordogne (France), dated to the Magdalenian period. This image (fig.7, 8), possibly related to water, shows an apparently dead snake thrown on his back, passive, on which a man with a stick on his shoulder turns his back. Significantly, the heads of two horses are added. Several current mythological motifs (shown to be, in fact, very old) and the comparison with other Paleolithic images (e.g. fig. 9) may give us an explanation. The horses as auxiliaries in the fight against the monster and the passivity of the defeated snake are motifs that are found among the first Indo-European narratives. Moreover, water is often associated with snakes in Paleolithic images (and are among, once again, the first Indo-European narratives). This second part of the paper is meant as independent support, and does not use statistics.

    Keywords: Comparative method, cultural evolution, gene-culture co-evolution, computational phylogenetics, cladistics, human prehistory, historical reconstruction, family tree, oral tradition, myths, folktales, ritual, serpent, dragon.

    Résumé: Dans la grotte ornée de Montespan et du Tuc d’Audoubert, toutes deux traversées d’une rivière qui sort de leur porche, ont été trouvées des serpents acéphales, déposés de main d’homme au Paléolithique supérieur. Leur acéphalie témoignerait de leur dangerosité supposée. Afin de comprendre le sens de ce rituel, j’ai tenté de reconstruire le proto-folklore entourant les serpents au Paléolithique supérieur, et ce en utilisant des outils phylogénétiques. Les résultats convergent avec ceux obtenus à partir de quatre autres bases de données. C’est la première fois qu’une telle consilience est mise en évidence en phylogénétique des mythes. Le folklore entourant les ophidiens semble avoir suivi les premières routes migratoires de l’humanité. L’arbre rend aussi possible la reconstruction du folklore paléolithique du serpent en Eurasie. Si on accepte les résultats obtenus, les rituels de Montespan et du Tuc d’Audoubert auraient pu servir à contrôler l’eau, en neutralisant symboliquement le dangereux et long serpent dispensateur de l’élément liquide. Ces résultats trouvent par ailleurs un écho dans plusieurs images rupestres et se voient prolongés par certains motifs très anciens de la mythologie européenne.

    Mots clés : Méthode comparative, évolution culturelle, coévolution gène-culture, phylogénétique, cladistique, préhistoire humaine, reconstruction historique, arbre généalogique, traditions orales, mythes, contes, rituels, serpent, dragon.

     

    Télécharger le fichier en pdf / download in pdf: dHuy.pdf